Problem solved! I added numbers to the "#contact_form_pop1", "#contact_form_pop2", etc. Hope this helps someone else.
<p class="contactformz">Dooby Du</p>
<div style="display:none" class="fancybox-hidden">
<div id="contact_form_pop1">
[contact-form-7 id="1305" title="I Have a Dooby Du Question"]
</div>
</div>